Quick Win Log · Compare · 5 min read

Stripe vs Square vs PayPal: which one fits your small business?

The short answer

Stripe tends to suit online sales, Square tends to suit in-person trade, and PayPal tends to suit customers who already want to pay with PayPal. Fees below are US figures read on 9 November 2026 and differ in other countries. If you mostly invoice, a bank transfer may cost you nothing.

By Kevin D’Ambros-Smith, founder of Simple-Growth. Published 2026-11-09. Updated 2026-11-09.

Stripe, Square and PayPal fees at a glance

StripeSquarePayPal
Online card payment2.9% + 30¢3.3% + 30¢ on Free plan; 2.9% + 30¢ on Plus2.99% + $0.49 for standard cards; 3.49% + $0.49 for PayPal Checkout
In person2.7% + 5¢ with Terminal2.6% + 15¢ on Free plan; 2.5% + 15¢ on PlusQR code: 2.29% + $0.09
Invoices0.4% per paid invoice on Starter invoicingACH 1%, $1 minimumCards 2.99% + $0.49; bank (ACH) 1%, capped at $10; subscription $14.99 a month listed for Invoicing
Monthly fee on standard card pricingNone stated$0 Free, $49 Plus, $149 Premium per locationNone stated for standard accounts
Payout timing as statedStandard schedule free: rolling, weekly or monthly. Instant: 1.5%, 50¢ minimumNext day transfers on every plan; instant for a fee (amount not stated)Instant transfer out of PayPal: 1.50%, $0.50 minimum
Dispute fee$15Not read on page$15 standard

Fees as read on each vendor's official US page on 9 November 2026, in US dollars. These are US fees. New Zealand and other countries differ: see vendor page.

Which one should you pick?

Choose Stripe if…

You sell mainly online, take bookings, or want payment links and invoices.

The online rate is simple and it has no monthly fee on standard pricing, as read.

Choose Square if…

Most of your sales happen face to face at a counter, stall or job site.

In-person rates are listed by plan and you can start on the Free plan, though you should check the online rate.

Choose PayPal if…

Your customers already want to pay with PayPal or Venmo.

It gives buyers a familiar button, but the fixed fee matters on small sales.

Choose neither if…

You send a handful of larger invoices to business customers.

Use bank transfer or a payment link from your accounting tool, and keep a card option for those who ask.

Why compare these three at all?

Picture this. A florist, a mobile car detailer and a freelance designer each ask the same question on the same week: "What is the least painful way to get paid by card?" Each has a different answer, because one sells at a counter, one at a driveway and one by email.

That is the real point. The cheapest headline rate is not automatically the cheapest for your small business. What matters is where your customers pay, how big your average sale is, and how much fiddling you can stand.

One caution before the numbers. Everything below is US pricing, read from each company's official page on 9 November 2026. If you are in New Zealand or elsewhere, rates, plans and features differ, so see the vendor page for your own country.

When does Stripe suit a small business?

Stripe is built around taking payments on a website, in an app or through a payment link. The page lists 2.9% + 30¢ for domestic online cards, with extra charges for manually entered cards, international cards and currency conversion.

It also sells card readers and a terminal rate of 2.7% + 5¢, so in person is possible. The strongest fit is a small business that sells online, takes bookings or subscriptions, or wants a tidy link to put on an invoice. Someone comfortable with a dashboard will be happy. Someone who wants a till on the counter on day one may not.

Invoices are worth a look too. The page lists 0.4% per paid invoice on Starter invoicing, and a capped 0.4% for invoices created through Checkout and Payment Links. Disputes cost $15 when received, so keep clear records of what you delivered and when.

When does Square suit a small business?

Square starts from the counter. Its plans run from a Free tier to $49 and $149 a month per location, and in-person rates step down as you move up: 2.6% + 15¢, 2.5% + 15¢, then 2.4% + 15¢.

The page notes you do not need hardware to take payments, as payment links, invoices and Tap to Pay on a phone work without it. Square is a natural fit for cafes, salons, market stalls and mobile trades where most sales happen face to face. Do the sums first, though. Online on the Free plan is 3.3% + 30¢, and keyed-in cards are 3.5% + 15¢.

When does PayPal suit a small business?

PayPal suits sellers whose customers already hold PayPal or Venmo and like paying that way. The page lists 3.49% + $0.49 for PayPal Checkout and 2.99% + $0.49 for standard card payments, plus 4.99% + $0.49 for Pay Later options.

The fixed fee bites on small sales, so check your average order before committing. Its QR code rate of 2.29% + $0.09 may interest you for in-person sales. PayPal also works as a second option next to another provider, so buyers can pick.

When should you choose none of them?

If you invoice a few business customers a month for larger amounts, card fees may be an expense you can avoid. A bank transfer costs nothing in most places, and many accounting tools can put a payment link on the invoice that routes to a bank payment or a card option you choose.

Ask what each customer actually prefers. Plenty of business buyers would rather pay by transfer, and you keep the whole amount. Keep a card option available for the people who want it, and decide with your own average invoice in front of you.

A simple test: if card fees on your last twenty invoices would have added up to more than an hour of your time is worth, it is worth asking each customer how they would like to pay before you build anything.

What does the difference look like on a real sale?

Here is a worked example, using only the US rates in the table. Say a customer pays 100 dollars online by standard card. At Stripe's listed 2.9% + 30¢ the fee is 3.20 dollars. At PayPal's listed 2.99% + $0.49 for standard cards it is 3.48 dollars. The gap is small.

Now say the sale is 20 dollars. The same rates give 88 cents and about 1.09 dollars. The fixed part of the fee now does more of the damage, which is why average sale size matters more than the headline percentage.

These are examples, not forecasts. Your plan, card mix and country will change the result, so run the sum with your own figures.

What should you check before you sign up?

Sources

Facts checked 9 November 2026. Prices and plans change, so confirm on the vendor’s page.

Questions people ask.

Which is cheapest for a small business?

It depends on your average sale and where it happens. Online, Stripe's listed 2.9% + 30¢ is lower than PayPal's checkout rate. In person, compare Square's plan rates and Stripe's terminal rate against your own sales.

Are these fees the same in New Zealand?

No. The fees in this article are US fees, read on 9 November 2026. New Zealand and other countries have different rates, plans and features, so see the vendor page for your own country.

Can I use more than one provider?

Yes. Many small businesses run one for in-person sales and another online, or add PayPal as an option next to a card provider. Check you can reconcile them in your accounting tool.

Do I have to take cards at all?

No. If your customers are businesses and your invoices are large, bank transfer costs less. Keep a card option for people who ask, and offer both on the invoice.

How fast will I get paid?

Only some timing is stated publicly. Stripe lists a free standard schedule and Square lists next day transfers, while PayPal lists a fee for instant transfers out. Confirm timing for your own region before you commit.

Want to find your next small business win?

Answer seven short questions and see where a small change is likely to matter most.

Take the 7-question quiz

Keep reading